Frazer traces similarities among ancient belief systems and presents theories regarding the. Written by cambridge classics fellow, james george frazer, the golden bough surveys the spiritual beliefs, practices, and religious institutions of cultures worldwide. Frazer to identify parallel patterns of ritual, symbols and belief across many centuries and many different cultures. Labyrinthine and universal in scope, the bough explores societys relationship with its natural environment, and how cycles of nature are reflected in human. The mythology in our language remarks on frazers golden. Mar 28, 2003 in its time, the golden bough influenced such luminaries as t. As anthropological studies go, i gather the golden bough has been left behind by more modern efforts. The golden bough is one of the episodic tales written in the epic aeneid, book vi, by the roman poet virgil 7019 bc, which narrates the adventures of the trojan hero aeneas after the trojan war.
Wittgensteins remarks on ritual, magic, religion, belief, ceremony, and frazers own logical presuppositions are as lucid and. Pdf doubt in wittgensteins remarks on frazers golden bough. James frazer s, the golden bough, is a must read for anyone interested in the comparative study of religion, folklore and magic. First published in 1890, the golden bough is a seminal work of modern anthropology. For example, the scanty bibliography of a rather vapid new work entitled philosophy of wicca lists frazers the golden bough, robert graves white goddess, and of course margaret murray, but not ronald hutton, carlo ginzberg, or any other deeply rooted contemporary historian. The text opens with frazers discussion of a famous painting, by the english painter william turner, of aeneass golden bough.
James george frazer and the golden bough arnold arboretum. The golden bough isbn 9781775410560 pdf epub james. It looks at concepts of the afterlife and the possibility of moving between this world and the next. It was thorough in its information, but lacked a spicy sense of humor that would keep the reader glued to the pages. A study in magic and religion, is an extraordinary work on the fundamentals of natural history. Frazers classic the golden bough may justifiably be called the foundation that modern anthropology is based on. In its time, the golden bough influenced such luminaries as t. Frazers influence also extends into the literary sphere, so one needs to have some familiarity when approaching work such as the wasteland.
The golden bough, his masterpiece, appeared in twelve volumes between 1890 and 1915. Ever since its first edition in 1890, the golden bough has been considered a major influence in the development of western thought. It was a transfigured landscape in a dreamlike vision of the woodland lake of nemi, diana s mirror, where religious ceremonies and the fulfillment of vows of priests and kings were held. Mar 14, 20 free kindle book and epub digitized and proofread by project gutenberg. The volumes of classicist sir james george frazers the golden bough published over two decades beginning in 1890 hit me like a thunderbolt. At that time, anthropology and philosophy were in close contact continental thinkers drew heavily on anthropologys theoretical terms, like mana, taboo, and potlatch, in order to help them explore the limits of human belief and imagination. A study in magic and religion erschien erstmals 1890, damals in zwei banden. Remarks on frazers golden bough by ludwig wittgenstein. View wittgenstein s remarks on frazer s golden bough research papers on academia. Wittgenstein wrote the text in the summer of 1931, which represented his earliest efforts to compose.
In 1931 ludwig wittgenstein wrote his famous remarks on frazers golden bough. Remarks on frazers golden bough is a collection of ludwig wittgensteins thoughts on james george frazers the golden bough. Bemerkungen uber frazers the golden bough is a collection of ludwig wittgensteins thoughts on james george frazers the golden bough. The commentary was initially published in 1967,1 with an english edition in 1979. Ludwig wittgenstein remarks on frazers golden bough emphasis in original in 1929 wittgenstein returned to cambridge to work out a new. It was published by james frazer in 1890, and is a seminal work in the field of comparative religion. A monumental study in folklore, mysticism, and religion, the golden bough is a classic introduction to comparative religious studies. The golden bough is a twelvevolume collection of mythology and accompanying commentary on the religions around those myths. Jan 05, 2014 the golden bough, james george frazer, apr 26, 2012, history, 410 pages.
In the following essay, mckenna shows how frazer s assumed cultural superiority over and distance from his subjects in the golden bough distinguish the work from a literary standpoint. Wittgensteins remarks on frazers golden bough research. In 1931 ludwig wittgenstein wrote his famous remarks on frazers golden bough, published posthumously in 1967. Wittgensteins remarks on frazers the golden bough nordic. The volumes of classicist sir james george frazer s the golden bough published over two decades beginning in 1890 hit me like a thunderbolt. The golden bough sir james frazer the golden bough. The golden bough by sir james george frazer, paperback. Aftermath p vithe books title was taken from an incident in. While it has been discredited in some areas since its 1st publication, it has stood the test of time remarkably well. Aimed at a broad literate audience raised on tales as told in bulfinchs the age of fable, frazers book joined the modernists in discussing religion dispassionately.
The golden bough is a classic in the truest sense of the word. Scottish social anthropologist sir james george frazers classic work, the golden bough. A study in religion and magic, james george frazer the golden bough. A study in magic and religion is a broad comparative study of mythology and religion. Check out the article when the bough breaks by jonathan z. This author is not unique, unfortunately, and it is easy to. Frazer the authoritative 1890 edition with an introduction by cairns craig and frazers own afterword. View wittgensteins remarks on frazers golden bough research papers on academia. When i first put pen to paper to write the golden bough i had no conception of the magnitude of the voyage on which i was embarking.
It was originally published in two volumes in 1890 with the subtitle a study in comparative religion and was enlarged and republished with the subtitle a study in magic and religion 12 volumes, 191115. Remarks on frazers golden bough is a collection of ludwig wittgensteins thoughts on james. A tenpage section of these re marks that wittgenstein grouped together addresses sir james george frazers book of cultural anthropology, the golden bough. The golden bough, perhaps the most famous work in anthropology, began appearing in 1890. A study in magic and religion in its second edition is a wideranging, comparative study of mythology and religion, written by the scottish anthropologist sir james george frazer. A study in comparative religion retitled the golden bough. Well, it depends on what part youre talking about, and which edition. The kindle version and the two linked from the online books page are abridged editions. The first edition came out in 2 volumes in 1890, and the second came out in 3 volumes in 1900. The golden bough is the bestknown work of james george frazer.
That said, frazers effort to answer a specific question by resorting to the general is comprehensive. Wittgensteins remarks on frazers golden bough preface. Disproving the popular thought that primitive life was simple, this monumental survey shows that savage man was enmeshed in a. A study in magic and religion is a wideranging, comparative study of mythology and religion, written by scottish anthropologist sir james george frazer 18541941. Turner s painting of the golden bough, a sacred grove where a certain tree grew day and night. In the following essay, mckenna shows how frazers assumed cultural superiority over and distance from his subjects in the golden bough distinguish the work from a literary standpoint literary critics have traced the influence of sir james frazers the golden bough through the works of authors as diverse as scott fitzgerald and sigmund freud. The commentary was initially published in 1967, with an english edition in 1979. The golden bough was first published in two volumes in 1890. Disproving the popular thought that primitive life was simple, this monumental survey shows that savage man was enmeshed in a tangle of magic, taboos, and superstitions. Wittgenstein, remarks on frazers golden bough ludwig. However, there is another edition, called ludwig wittgenstein.
Published originally in two volumes in 1890, this extraordinary study of primitive myth and magic led scottish anthropologist j. James frazers, the golden bough, is a must read for anyone interested in the comparative study of religion, folklore and magic. Smith, which is the best explanation of frazers project and why it fails. This abridged version of a multivolumed master work will open your eyes to the commonality amongst traditional religious beliefs and practices around the world. The golden bough, a study of comparative religion by sir james frazer. Eliot and robert graves, who were more likely to have read all twelve volumes. Free kindle book and epub digitized and proofread by project gutenberg. Whether in the context of religion or not, authority is not the issue here, nor is belief or at least not very much. Parts of the golden bough frazer 1922 were read to him in 1930 and his remarks 1979 on frazer were written down by hand in the summer of 1931. The golden bough, james george frazer, apr 26, 2012, history, 410 pages. Wikipedia article, commons category, wikidata item a broad comparative cultural study of mythology and religion by scottish anthropologist sir james george frazer 18541941. Publication date 1894 topics mythology, religion, primitive, magic, superstition. The greatly revised and enlarged twelvevolume third edition 191115 of sir james frazers controversial work on classical religion the postmodern condition a report on knowledge, jeanfran.
While troy was being destroyed in its last battle against the greeks, aeneas left the city and led a quest to find a new and hesperian home. Third and best edition, later issue, of frazers landmark anthropological study of magic and religion, greatly enlarged and expanded to 12 volumes. The golden bough could almost could be said to comprise a modern mythology about mythology. The golden bough wikisource, the free online library. Golden bough james george frazer bauman rare books. Remarkable for its vast assembly of facts and its charm of presentation, it offers the thesis that man progresses from magic through religious belief to scientific. It was thorough in it s information, but lacked a spicy sense of humor that would keep the reader glued to the pages. Wittgensteins remarks on frazers golden bough notes. Remarks on frazer s golden bough emphasis in original in 1929 wittgenstein returned to cambridge to work out a new philosophy. The kindle version and the two linked from the on line books page are abridged editions. The bland, widely available onevolume condensation should be avoided like the plague.
Aug 18, 2014 scottish social anthropologist sir james george frazers classic work, the golden bough. A study in magic and religon, was a well written book that i would reccomend to those with a bit of time on their hands. A study in magic and religion by james george frazer. His most famous work, the golden bough 1890, documents and details similar magical and religious beliefs across the globe. This massive work surveys the spiritual beliefs, practices, and institutions. Originally a twovolume work, sir james george frazer eventually expanded it to twelve volumes, the last of. Literary critics have traced the influence of sir james frazer s the golden bough through the works of authors as diverse as scott fitzgerald and sigmund freud. I thought only to explain a single rule of an ancient italian priesthood.
Remarks on frazers golden bough ludwig wittgenstein on. Frazer, a cambridge researcher trained in classical literature, outlines ancient myths and folk legends, proposing that all civilizations go through three stages of development. Wittgensteins remarks on frazers golden bough notes, page 1. Remarks on frazer s golden bough is a collection of ludwig wittgenstein s thoughts on james george frazer s the golden bough. This volume is dedicated to wittgensteins remarks on frazers the golden bough and represents a collaboration of scholars within philosophy and the study of. Treating religion as a cultural phenomenon rather than discussing it from a theological perspective, the effect of the golden bough on both european literature and the emerging discipline of anthropology was substantial. The golden bough sir james frazer the golden bough describes our ancestors primitive methods of worship, sex practices, strange rituals and festivals. The germ for frazers thesis was the preroman priestking at the fane of nemi, who was murdered ritually by his successor. Sir james george frazer was a scottish social anthropologist influential in the early stages of the modern studies of mythology and comparative religion. Wellwritten, compendious in its scholarship, profound in its influence, shocking in its implications, frazer has penned one of mankind s great unread books. A classic study of the beliefs and institutions of mankind that traces the development and confluence of thought from magic and ritual to modern scientific theory, it has been a source of great influence upon such diverse writers as t. Remarks on frazer s golden bough paperback by ludwig wittgenstein another useful book mercifully collected by rush rhys we owe him a lot for his recordings of snatches of wittgenstein s thoughts.
712 585 1103 115 1393 252 308 1157 801 1341 578 53 243 649 1070 323 1366 214 857 200 1104 1178 747 681 576 570 1281 1404 1069 1188 305 971 26 238 111 1090 648